Industry News  |  In Practice  |  The Bigger Picture  |  Digital Marketing  |  Your Business

Latest Articles

Alexander McCall-Smith Engages Web 2.0

The Daily Telegraph is in the middle of a 20-week serialisation of an online book created by author Alexander McCall-Smith, his first such project. New Media Knowledge caught up with the organisers to discuss ‘Corduroy Mansions’.

more

Business Brief: Video Advertising Looks to Future

Google has announced it will incentivise advertisers on its video properties as well as launching research programmes into how Web users consume Internet video material. New Media Knowledge spoke to a number of industry players to gauge their views on where the video advertising market is going.

more

‘Virtual Home’ for Ex-Pats in London Established

A social network aimed at providing information for ex-pats living in London has been established. New Media Knowledge met the site’s co-founder to find out more.

more

Related Articles

Conversations and Connections

Filed under: all articles
By: NMK Created on: May 26th, 2007
Bookmark this article with: Delicious Digg StumbleUpon

A new paper from Social Tapestries reports on attempts to use internet-based tools to encourage participation and involvement in local issues. While the project has been deemed a failure, the process provided some interesting lessons for policy makers and practitioners.

A new paper from Social Tapestries reports on attempts to use internet-based tools to encourage participation and involvement in local issues. While the project has been deemed a failure, the process provided some interesting lessons for policy makers and practitioners.

The research groups Social Tapestries and Proboscis worked alongide the Havelock Residents' Association on the Havelock estate in West London, aiming to deploy a range of tools, based around knowledge mapping and sharing, to encourage connections and participation within the community.

While many of the project's initiatives were offline, forming a committee, creating printed materials and attempting to raise funding for the community shop, some of the more interesting initiatives came through online activity. A committee member had spent some time cataloguing faulty lights on the estate. Proboscis responded by entering geo-spatial data into their mapping system, to create a system similar to the MySociety Neighbourhood Fixit application.

They also created a number of video interviews with residents, cataloguing their experience of living on the estate, from which a DVD was produced. They also created two 'StoryCubes' (pictures and text arranged in three dimensions to illustrate an issue or a theme).

Next they developed a public authoring system - bringing together maps, data, knowledge, images and video - using Blogger, EditGrid, Google Maps and flickr to assimilate the information. The results are at http://havelocktapestry.blogspot.com.

Sadly, the project was felt to be a failure by the group. The account given in the full report is a catalogue of unattended meetings, unwillingness to volunteer and tensions between the committee itself, whereby a younger committee member who demonstrated an affinity with the IT resources became alienated and left the project.

The report concludes with a number of policy messages or lessons from the project. Foremost, the premise that voluteers be put in a position that ought to be provided by official sources is weak. People's energies run dry and commitments take them elsewhere. Second, such projects need to be extremely sensitive to the local 'orgscape' - the existing relationships and opportunities that exist within a community. Third, a wide variety of types of input need to be provided to find the widest reach for their influence. Lastly, "community development has to be taken seriously by local partners, and not delivered in a piecemeal and half-hearted way."

Comments

You must be logged in to comment.

Log into NMK

Register

Lost Password?
Login

Newsletter


For the latest news from NMK enter your email address and click subscribe:


Subscribe