Industry News  |  In Practice  |  The Bigger Picture  |  Digital Marketing  |  Your Business

Latest Articles

More Web 2.0 Needed In Schools

An influential think-tank calling for more Web 2.0 use in school and technology experts agree, arguing that children should get used to collaborative tools before they enter the workplace.

more

UK Council for Child Internet Safety Launches

The UK Government launched its programme to help protect children from exposure to potentially harmful content on the Internet, including some forms of advertising. New Media Knowledge spoke to AOL, one of the companies involved, to see what real impact the new group would have.

more

US Presidential Election Gets Social

Last week, Twitter launched its US Presidential Election microblogging site and, with social media likely to play a big part in the outcome, politicians this side of the pond should be looking closely at its impact, experts say.

more

Related Articles

Related Events

The Facebook Elephant

Filed under: all articles
By: NMK Created on: January 3rd, 2008
Bookmark this article with: Delicious Digg StumbleUpon

Following claims that social networking sites, such as Facebook could turn out to be a costly ‘white elephant’ for businesses, Tim Hoang reports on how the Web 2.0 world has reacted.

It was reported on business and technology news site, Silicon.com that analyst house Gartner had fired a warning to businesses who ‘rushed to invest’ in ‘Facebook-led web 2.0 hype’.

Describing the technology as ‘a costly white elephant’, the article highlighted how businesses should carefully consider how they would protect personal intellectual property and people’s preferences for using existing non-professional external social networks before they developed their own.

Despite evidence that companies would find it easier to develop their own social networks with Facebook licensing out its developer platform, Gartner’s research apparently alleged that ‘the hype around social networking doesn’t necessarily mean it’s a mature enough technology to make it a critical business requirement’. The article continued: ‘There is also little evidence that social networking will be as beneficial for businesses as other web-based communications tech".

However, some bloggers have hit back at the report. Influential blogger, Euan Semple simply asked his readers to "Ignore Gartner". However, this was soon updated to ‘Ignore Silicon’ as it became apparent that the report, according to Edward Charvet of Internet strategy consultants, Trovus, did not summarise Gartner’s report in a "fair and balanced manner".

"The article from Silicon was making reference to a recent Gartner thought piece, making you think that Gartner’s position was simply that social computing is crap and has no value for a clutch of reasons," said Charvet on his company blog, Rewarding Dialogue.

"It’s not the hellfire and brimstone that the Silicon article will have you believe.  The points Gartner make seem to be to be that Social Computing, like any application set, may be hampered in delivering value if the "human" element is ignore," continued Charvet.

Ken Camp, from digital media experts, Stardust Global Ventures believes that businesses should actually be investing more rather than less, resources into understanding the value of social media and how it can benefit business operations.

"Gartner says that social media technology isn’t mature enough to make it a critical business requirement. I don’t agree. It’s a rapidly emerging tool that’s becoming more vital to success in business every day. The problem is that businesses aren’t investing resources to understand how to capture the value. The value proposition of social media isn’t understood by enterprise business. I don’t think Gartner understands it either," he said.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment.

Log into NMK

Register

Lost Password?
Login

Newsletter


For the latest news from NMK enter your email address and click subscribe:


Subscribe